When James Howells began mining Bitcoin in 2009, few could have predicted the cryptocurrency’s meteoric rise in value. The Welsh IT engineer successfully mined approximately 7,500 Bitcoins during the currency’s infancy, when it was merely a curiosity among a small circle of tech enthusiasts. His story has become legendary in the cryptocurrency community as a cautionary tale about digital asset storage.
The costly disposal that made headlines
In 2013, Howells made a discovery that would haunt him for years to come. Bitcoin had surpassed the $1,000 mark, suddenly valuing his digital wallet at approximately $7.5 million. His excitement quickly turned to despair when he realized the hard drive containing his private keys was nowhere to be found.
After careful investigation, Howells reached a devastating conclusion – he had accidentally thrown away the hard drive containing his Bitcoin fortune during a home cleanup. The device had been discarded and transported to a landfill in Newport, Wales, where it remains buried to this day.
As Bitcoin’s value continued to climb over the years, Howells’ lost fortune grew exponentially. By 2025, the misplaced 7,500 Bitcoins would be worth an estimated $700 million (€700 million), making this perhaps the most expensive accidental disposal in history.
Recovery attempts and technical challenges
Since realizing his mistake, Howells has devised increasingly sophisticated plans to recover his buried treasure. His most recent proposal in 2021 involved:
- Excavating a specific 200 square meter area to a depth of 15 meters
- Employing specialized equipment and environmental safeguards
- Utilizing NASA technology to expedite the search process
- Completing the operation within a 12-month timeframe
- Sharing recovered funds with the Newport City Council
Howells has assembled a team of experts in data recovery and excavation, offering the Newport City Council a substantial percentage of any recovered funds. Despite these proposals, the council has consistently denied access to the landfill site, citing environmental regulations and practical concerns.
The technical challenges of recovering the hard drive remain formidable. Even if located, the device would have suffered significant environmental damage, requiring specialized data recovery techniques.
| Year | Bitcoin Value | Estimated Worth of Howells’ 7,500 BTC |
|---|---|---|
| 2009 | $0 | $0 |
| 2013 | $1,000 | $7.5 million |
| 2021 | $40,000 | $300 million |
| 2025 | $93,000 | $700 million |
Legal battle reaches disappointing conclusion
Howells’ frustration culminated in legal action against the Newport City Council. However, in January 2025, his hopes were dealt a severe blow when a judge dismissed his case during its initial hearing. The court ruled there were no reasonable grounds for the lawsuit and “no realistic prospect” of success in a full trial.
The judge emphasized two critical points: first, that the hard drive legally became city property upon entering the landfill, and second, that environmental regulations would prohibit the extensive excavation required regardless of ownership claims.
Following the ruling, Howells expressed his disappointment on social media platform X, stating: “This decision has taken everything from me and left me with nothing. It’s the great British injustice system striking again.” He particularly lamented being denied the opportunity to present his case in a full trial, where he believed additional context could have influenced the outcome.
Despite this setback, Howells has indicated he may appeal the decision, though legal experts suggest his chances of overturning the ruling remain slim. His story continues to serve as a stark reminder of both Bitcoin’s extraordinary value appreciation and the unique challenges of securing digital assets in the cryptocurrency era.
